Re: adventure 2 battle or shadow?

SA2 Battle was more well-received than Shadow the Hedgehog and is certainly more beloved by fans today. Shadow the Hedgehog is best known as the Sonic game where the main character says "damn" and uses a gun. As a kid, I never had SA2. I had the first Sonic Adventure, I had Shadow, and I had Sonic Heroes, and out of those three Sonic Heroes was my favorite.

now, im about to download a sonic game. and im stuck between shadow the hedgehog (2005) and SA2 battle, which one should i choose?